Peer Review Process

  1. Peer Review Policy

BALANCE: Jurnal Akuntansi, Auditing dan Keuangan implements a Double-Blind Peer Review process to ensure the objectivity, fairness, confidentiality, and academic quality of published manuscripts.

Under this process, the identities of authors and reviewers are mutually concealed throughout the peer review process. Authors are not informed of the identities of the reviewers, and reviewers are not provided with information identifying the authors.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their submitted manuscripts do not contain identifying information, including names, institutional affiliations, acknowledgments, or other details that could reveal their identities during the review process. Document properties and metadata should also be checked to ensure author anonymity.

  1. Initial Editorial Screening

All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening conducted by the editor. This stage evaluates the manuscript's:

  1. Suitability for the journal's Focus and Scope.
  2. Compliance with the Author Guidelines and manuscript template.
  3. Originality and potential contribution to the field.
  4. Academic relevance and overall manuscript quality.
  5. Appropriateness of the research methodology and presentation.
  6. Compliance with the journal's publication ethics and submission requirements.

The editorial team may conduct an initial similarity screening to identify potential plagiarism or inappropriate text reuse.

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements or fall outside its scope may be rejected at this stage without proceeding to external peer review. The editor may also request corrections or additional information before the manuscript proceeds to the next stage.

  1. Reviewer Assignment

Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are assigned to qualified reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area of the submitted manuscript.

The editorial team selects reviewers based on their academic qualifications, research expertise, and relevance to the manuscript's topic. Reviewers are expected to provide objective, independent, and constructive assessments.

Reviewers must disclose any potential conflicts of interest that could affect their impartiality. A reviewer who feels unqualified to evaluate the manuscript or unable to complete the review within the required timeframe should notify the editor and decline the assignment.

  1. Double-Blind Review Process

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts without knowing the authors' identities. Similarly, authors do not know the identities of the reviewers.

The review focuses on the following aspects:

  • Originality and contribution to accounting knowledge.
  • Relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope.
  • Adequacy of the theoretical foundation and literature review.
  • Appropriateness of research design and methodology.
  • Quality of data analysis and interpretation.
  • Clarity of presentation and academic writing.
  • Validity of conclusions and implications.

Reviewers are expected to provide clear, constructive, and evidence-based comments to help authors improve their manuscripts.

All manuscripts, reviewer identities, review reports, and editorial communications are treated confidentially throughout the editorial process.

  1. Editorial Decision

Based on the reviewers' comments and recommendations, the editor makes an editorial decision. The possible decisions include:

  • Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication without further substantive revision.
  • Minor Revision: Limited revisions are required before further editorial consideration.
  • Major Revision: Substantial revisions are required, and the revised manuscript may undergo further evaluation.
  • Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's publication standards or requirements.

The final editorial decision rests with the editor, taking into consideration the reviewers' recommendations, the manuscript's academic quality, and the journal's editorial policies. The editor is not required to adopt reviewers' recommendations automatically.

  1. Revision and Re-evaluation

Authors receiving revision decisions are required to revise their manuscripts in accordance with the reviewers' comments and editorial recommendations.

Authors must submit:

  1. A revised manuscript incorporating the required changes.
  2. A point-by-point response explaining how each reviewer comment has been addressed.

If authors do not agree with a particular reviewer comment, they should provide a clear academic justification in their response.

Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers for further evaluation when necessary. The editor evaluates the revised manuscript and determines whether additional revisions are required or whether the manuscript can proceed to the next publication stage.

  1. No Fast-Track Publication

BALANCE does not provide fast-track review or expedited publication services. All submitted manuscripts must follow the same established editorial workflow and Double-Blind Peer Review procedures.

The manuscript processing time depends on the editorial workflow, reviewer availability, the quality of the manuscript, and the authors' responsiveness to revision requests.

No special arrangements are available to accelerate the review or publication process. All manuscripts are treated equally under the journal's established editorial procedures.

  1. Confidentiality and Ethical Responsibilities

Editors and reviewers are required to maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and review reports. Manuscripts under review must not be used for personal advantage or disclosed to unauthorized parties.

Reviewers must declare any potential conflicts of interest and notify the editor if they are unable to provide an objective assessment.

Reviewers must not use unpublished materials, data, or ideas from manuscripts under review for personal or professional advantage. They must not contact authors directly regarding a manuscript under review without the editor's permission.

Editors and reviewers must also comply with the journal's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement, including its provisions on confidentiality, objectivity, conflicts of interest, and research integrity.

All participants in the editorial and peer review process are expected to uphold academic integrity, objectivity, confidentiality, and ethical publishing standards.