Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

BALANCE: Jurnal Akuntansi, Auditing dan Keuangan

  1. Introduction

BALANCE: Jurnal Akuntansi, Auditing dan Keuangan is committed to maintaining high standards of publication ethics, academic integrity, and responsible scholarly publishing. The journal expects all parties involved in the publication process, including editors, reviewers, authors, and the publisher, to uphold ethical principles and professional standards.

BALANCE follows the principles and relevant guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) in addressing publication ethics issues and potential research misconduct. This statement outlines the ethical responsibilities of editors, authors, and reviewers and establishes the journal's approach to preventing and addressing publication misconduct.

The journal is committed to ensuring that editorial decisions and publication processes are conducted fairly, transparently, objectively, and independently.

  1. Responsibilities of Editors

Editors are responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts are evaluated fairly, objectively, and confidentially. Editorial decisions must be based on the manuscript's academic quality, originality, relevance to the journal's focus and scope, methodological rigor, and contribution to the field.

Editors are expected to:

  1. Evaluate manuscripts based on their scholarly merit without discrimination based on the authors' gender, nationality, institutional affiliation, religion, or other personal characteristics.
  2. Ensure that manuscripts are handled in accordance with the journal's editorial policies and Double-Blind Peer Review procedure.
  3. Select reviewers who have appropriate expertise and no identifiable conflicts of interest that could compromise the review process.
  4. Maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts, reviewer identities, and all information obtained during the editorial process.
  5. Make editorial decisions independently and objectively, without inappropriate influence from commercial, institutional, personal, or other non-academic interests.
  6. Ensure that editorial decisions are supported by relevant scholarly assessments and the journal's publication standards.
  7. Declare any potential conflict of interest and withdraw from handling a manuscript when necessary.
  8. Take appropriate action when suspected ethical violations, plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, or other forms of misconduct are identified.
  9. Consider corrections, retractions, or expressions of concern when necessary to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record.
  10. Treat authors, reviewers, and other parties involved in the publication process professionally and respectfully.

Editors must not use unpublished information, data, arguments, or findings from submitted manuscripts for their own research or personal advantage without the authors' explicit permission.

The Editor-in-Chief and relevant editorial editors are responsible for ensuring that editorial policies are consistently implemented throughout the publication process.

  1. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts meet standards of academic integrity, originality, and ethical research conduct. Authors must accurately represent their research processes, data, analysis, and findings.

Authors are expected to:

  1. Submit original work that has not been previously published and is not currently under consideration by another journal.
  2. Ensure that the manuscript is not submitted to more than one journal simultaneously.
  3. Avoid redundant or duplicate publication. Substantial reuse of previously published work must be transparently disclosed and appropriately justified.
  4. Avoid dividing the results of a single study into multiple publications solely to increase the number of submitted or published articles (salami publication).
  5. Ensure that all research data, analysis, and findings are accurate and honestly presented.
  6. Refrain from fabricating, falsifying, manipulating, or selectively misrepresenting data, research materials, images, or results.
  7. Provide appropriate citations and references for ideas, theories, data, and findings obtained from other sources.
  8. Obtain permission for the use of copyrighted materials when required and acknowledge the original sources appropriately.
  9. Ensure that all individuals listed as authors have made meaningful scholarly contributions and have approved the final version of the manuscript.
  10. Obtain explicit approval from all co-authors before submitting the manuscript.
  11. Disclose relevant funding sources and potential conflicts of interest.
  12. Obtain ethical approval and informed consent when required for research involving human participants, in accordance with applicable institutional and regulatory requirements.
  13. Protect the privacy, confidentiality, and rights of research participants.
  14. Disclose the use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools in accordance with the journal's Author Guidelines.
  15. Respond appropriately to editorial and reviewer comments and provide corrections when errors are identified.
  16. Provide relevant documentation or research data to support the validity of reported findings when reasonably requested by the editorial team, subject to confidentiality, privacy, and applicable legal restrictions.

Authors whose names appear on a submitted manuscript share responsibility and accountability for the integrity of the research and the accuracy of the published work.

  1. Responsibilities of Reviewers

Peer review assists editors in making informed editorial decisions and helps authors improve the quality of their manuscripts. Reviewers are expected to conduct evaluations objectively, professionally, and constructively.

Reviewers are expected to:

  1. Accept review assignments only when they have appropriate expertise and sufficient time to complete the review.
  2. Inform the editor if they feel unqualified to evaluate the research or cannot complete the review within the required timeframe.
  3. Declare any potential conflict of interest before accepting or proceeding with a review.
  4. Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and all information obtained during the review process.
  5. Evaluate manuscripts objectively, providing clear, evidence-based, and constructive comments.
  6. Assess the originality, theoretical contribution, research methodology, data analysis, interpretation of findings, and relevance of the manuscript.
  7. Identify relevant published works that have not been appropriately cited.
  8. Inform the editor of any suspected plagiarism, substantial similarity, duplicate publication, data fabrication, data falsification, or other ethical concerns.
  9. Complete reviews within the agreed timeframe or inform the editor if additional time is required.
  10. Treat authors and their work professionally and respectfully.

Reviewers must not use unpublished materials, data, arguments, or findings from manuscripts under review for personal research or professional advantage. Reviewers must not contact authors directly regarding a manuscript under review without the editor's permission.

  1. Confidentiality and Double-Blind Peer Review

BALANCE applies a Double-Blind Peer Review policy. Under this process, the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another throughout the review process.

All manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. Editors and reviewers must not disclose manuscript contents, authors' identities, reviewers' identities, or editorial discussions to unauthorized individuals.

Reviewers must not share manuscripts or review reports with other parties without the editor's permission. Unpublished materials, information, and ideas obtained through peer review must not be used for personal or professional advantage without the authors' express written consent.

Authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to respect the confidentiality and integrity of the peer-review process.

  1. Plagiarism and Similarity Screening

BALANCE does not accept plagiarism or any form of unattributed use of another person's work.

All submitted manuscripts may be screened using similarity-checking software. The editorial team evaluates similarity reports contextually, considering the nature of overlapping text, appropriate attribution, quotations, references, and the originality of the manuscript.

A similarity percentage alone does not determine whether plagiarism has occurred. The editorial team will assess the content and circumstances of any identified overlap before making an editorial decision.

Manuscripts containing substantial unattributed similarities, inappropriate reuse of previously published work, or other indications of plagiarism may be rejected.

If plagiarism or other forms of inappropriate text or data reuse are identified after publication, the journal may take further action, including correction or retraction, as appropriate.

  1. Research Misconduct

BALANCE considers the following practices to be forms of research or publication misconduct:

  • Plagiarism: Using another person's ideas, words, data, or work without appropriate acknowledgment.
  • Data fabrication: Inventing data, research materials, or results that were not obtained through the reported research process.
  • Data falsification: Manipulating research materials, processes, data, images, or results in a way that misrepresents the research.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication: Publishing substantially the same work in more than one publication without appropriate disclosure and justification.
  • Simultaneous submission: Submitting the same manuscript to BALANCE and another journal at the same time.
  • Salami publication: Inappropriately dividing the findings of a single study into multiple publications to increase the number of publications.
  • Authorship misconduct: Inappropriately including or excluding individuals as authors or misrepresenting their contributions.
  • Citation manipulation: Deliberately including irrelevant citations or engaging in inappropriate citation practices to influence citation metrics.
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest: Failing to disclose relationships or interests that could influence the research or its interpretation.
  • Unethical research practices: Conducting research involving human participants without appropriate ethical consideration, approval, or informed consent when required.

When suspected misconduct is identified, the editorial team will assess the available evidence and may request explanations, relevant documentation, or supporting data from the parties concerned.

The author or authors involved will be given an opportunity to respond to the allegations before an editorial decision is made, where appropriate. The journal will handle such cases confidentially and objectively, with reference to relevant COPE guidance.

Depending on the seriousness and nature of the misconduct, the journal may take one or more of the following actions:

  1. Reject the manuscript if it is still under consideration.
  2. Request clarification, corrections, or additional documentation from the authors.
  3. Issue a correction or erratum if the article has already been published and the identified issue can be appropriately corrected.
  4. Retract the published article in cases of serious misconduct or when the reliability or integrity of the article is substantially compromised.
  5. Inform the authors' affiliated institution or other relevant authorities when appropriate.

The action taken will depend on the available evidence, the seriousness of the violation, and the potential impact on the integrity of the scholarly record.

  1. Authorship and Contributorship

Authorship must reflect substantial scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript. Individuals listed as authors must have made meaningful contributions to the conception or design of the research, data collection, analysis or interpretation, or the development and critical revision of the manuscript.

All listed authors must:

  1. Approve the final version of the manuscript.
  2. Agree to the submission of the manuscript to BALANCE.
  3. Accept collective responsibility and accountability for the integrity of the work.
  4. Be able to identify their respective contributions to the research and manuscript.

Individuals who have provided assistance but do not meet the criteria for authorship may be acknowledged appropriately in the Acknowledgment section.

The addition, removal, or rearrangement of authors after submission must be supported by a reasonable explanation and agreement from all authors concerned, subject to the editor's consideration.

  1. Conflict of Interest

All authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose any financial, professional, institutional, personal, or other relationships that could reasonably be perceived as influencing their judgment or decisions.

Authors must disclose relevant conflicts of interest in their submitted manuscripts. If no conflict of interest exists, authors should explicitly state that there is no conflict of interest.

Reviewers must inform the editor of any potential conflict before accepting or proceeding with a review. Such conflicts may arise from competitive, collaborative, personal, institutional, or other relationships with the authors or organizations associated with the manuscript.

Editors must not handle manuscripts when a conflict of interest could compromise their impartiality. Where necessary, alternative reviewers or editors will be appointed to maintain the integrity of the editorial process.

Reviewers should recommend citations to their own work or the work of their associates only when scientifically relevant and necessary. Citation recommendations must not be made primarily to increase citation counts or personal visibility.

  1. Ethical Approval and Informed Consent

Research involving human participants, including surveys, interviews, observations, and experiments, must comply with applicable ethical standards and institutional requirements.

Authors must provide information about ethical approval, including:

  1. The name of the approving ethics committee or institutional review board, where applicable.
  2. The ethical approval number.
  3. The approval date.
  4. A statement explaining how informed consent was obtained.
  5. An explanation of how participants' privacy, confidentiality, and anonymity were protected.

Evidence of ethical approval must be provided when required by the journal.

If formal ethical approval was not required or the study was exempt, authors must explain the basis for the exemption and provide supporting documentation when available.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that research participants are adequately informed about the purpose of the research, their participation, and the use of their information. The rights, privacy, and confidentiality of participants must be protected throughout the research process and publication.

The editorial team may request additional information or supporting evidence when necessary.

  1. Use of Artificial Intelligence

BALANCE recognizes that generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools may support certain research and writing activities. However, authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, integrity, and academic quality of their manuscripts.

Authors may use AI tools for appropriate supporting activities, such as language improvement, translation, brainstorming, outlining, coding assistance, data analysis support, and visualization. Such use must not replace the authors' intellectual contribution, critical judgment, or responsibility for the research.

Authors must disclose the use of generative AI tools in accordance with the journal's Author Guidelines. The disclosure should identify the AI tool used, its purpose, and the relevant activities or sections of the manuscript for which it was used.

If no generative AI tools were used, authors must provide an explicit statement indicating that no such tools were used in preparing the manuscript.

AI tools cannot be listed as authors because they cannot assume responsibility for the content, accuracy, and integrity of a scholarly publication.

Editors and reviewers must maintain manuscript confidentiality. They must not upload unpublished manuscripts or confidential editorial materials to public AI platforms or other third-party services when doing so could compromise confidentiality, unless explicitly authorized and adequate safeguards are in place.

Editorial and review responsibilities must remain with the designated human editors and reviewers. AI tools must not replace human judgment in editorial decisions or peer-review evaluations.

  1. Complaints and Appeals

BALANCE is committed to handling complaints and appeals concerning editorial decisions and publication practices objectively, fairly, and confidentially.

Authors may submit complaints or appeals concerning editorial decisions or the conduct of the publication process to the Editor-in-Chief through the journal's official communication channels.

Complaints and appeals should include a clear explanation of the concern and relevant supporting information, where available.

The Editor-in-Chief or an appropriate editorial representative will examine the concerns and determine whether further investigation or action is necessary.

An editor who is directly involved in a complaint or has a conflict of interest must not be responsible for handling that case. Another appropriate editor or representative may be assigned to ensure impartial consideration.

The submission of an appeal does not guarantee a change in the original editorial decision. Decisions will be based on relevant evidence, journal policies, and principles of publication ethics.

  1. Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern

BALANCE is committed to preserving the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record.

When significant errors or ethical concerns are identified in a published article, the journal will evaluate the matter and take appropriate action. Depending on the circumstances, this may include:

Correction or Erratum

A correction may be issued when an error is identified in a published article but does not invalidate the overall findings or conclusions. Corrections will be clearly identified and linked to the original article.

Retraction

An article may be retracted when serious errors, research misconduct, or other circumstances substantially undermine the reliability or integrity of the published work. A retraction notice will explain the reason for the retraction and be linked to the original article.

Expression of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when substantial questions have been raised about a published article but an investigation is ongoing or the available evidence is insufficient for a final decision.

The journal will consider relevant COPE guidance when determining the appropriate action. Any correction, retraction, or expression of concern will be handled transparently to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.

  1. Publisher Responsibilities and Editorial Independence

BALANCE is published by the Faculty of Business and Social Innovation, Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia.

The publisher supports the journal in maintaining editorial quality, publication integrity, and the sustainability of its publishing activities.

Editorial decisions concerning the evaluation, acceptance, revision, or rejection of manuscripts remain the responsibility of the journal's editorial team.

The publisher must not improperly influence editorial decisions based on commercial, institutional, personal, or other non-academic interests.

The publisher and editorial team share a commitment to maintaining ethical publishing practices and protecting the integrity of the scholarly record.

  1. Commitment to Publication Ethics

BALANCE is committed to addressing ethical concerns consistently, fairly, and transparently. All parties involved in the publication process are expected to comply with this statement and the journal's other publication policies.

The journal may revise its ethical policies when necessary to reflect developments in scholarly publishing standards, relevant publication ethics guidance, and changes in editorial practices.

By submitting a manuscript to BALANCE, authors acknowledge their responsibility to comply with the journal's publication ethics policies and applicable standards of research integrity.

Journal: BALANCE: Jurnal Akuntansi, Auditing dan Keuangan
Publisher: Faculty of Business and Social Innovation, Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia
Peer Review Model: Double-Blind Peer Review
Publication Ethics Reference: Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) – https://publicationethics.org/